HomeBlogSEO

How to find a good SEO consultant: questions to ask and red flags.

An honest buyer's guide for UK business owners: where to look, what to ask, what good reporting looks like, and the warning signs to walk away from.

A checklist of four questions to ask an SEO consultant

The short version

  • Before you look, write down what SEO needs to do for the business, such as more calls from a particular town or more sales of one product range. Then look for someone who has done that kind of work.
  • A good consultant asks you questions before quoting, and can explain what they’d look at first on your site and why.
  • Walk away from guaranteed rankings, secret methods, bulk link packages and anyone who wants your accounts in their name.
  • You should own your domain, website, Google Business Profile, Search Console and Analytics, whoever you hire.
  • Good reporting connects the month’s work to enquiries and sales, with rankings as supporting evidence.

Anyone in the UK can call themselves an SEO consultant. There’s no licence, and Google doesn’t certify SEO practitioners. So the person who turns up when you search for help could be excellent or useless, and the sales pitch often sounds the same either way. This guide gives you the questions to ask and the warning signs that tell them apart.

We’re an SEO agency, so we’re one of the options you might be weighing up. Everything below applies to us as much as anyone else.

Decide what you need before you look

SEO covers a lot of ground: showing up in the map results, technical fixes, new pages and content, links from other sites, product and category pages for shops. Most consultants are stronger in some of these than others. Before you speak to anyone, write down what success would look like in a year (more calls from a particular area, more sales of a product range, more enquiries for a higher-value service), what’s been tried before and what you can spend each month. It makes first conversations quicker and lets you compare proposals properly.

Then decide what kind of help suits you.

The main options, who they suit, and what to check.
OptionUsually suitsCheck
Freelance consultantSmaller sites, one clear need, or advice your own team will carry outWhether they do the work or only advise, and how much time they have for you
Specialist agencyOngoing work across technical, content and links, or SEO run alongside paid adsWho works on your account after the sale
Large agencyBig sites and budgets, businesses with their own marketing teamMinimum fees, and how much attention a smaller account gets
Do it yourself with paid guidanceOwners with time who want to learnWhether you’ll really find the hours each month

Where to find an SEO consultant

  • Recommendations from businesses like yours. Ask what changed in their enquiries or sales, and how the consultant communicates when things go slowly.
  • Google reviews. Read the detailed ones, and look for reviews that mention results and how problems were handled.
  • LinkedIn, local business networks and trade associations in your sector.
  • Search results. A consultant who ranks for their own services has shown they can do it for themselves, although plenty of good consultants get all their work by referral and don’t bother.
  • Directories and review platforms can help you build a list. Treat paid placements on them as advertising.

Aim for a shortlist of two or three, and talk to each properly before asking for a proposal.

Questions to ask an SEO consultant

These questions are designed to show how someone thinks and how they work. The answers matter more than the polish.

Questions to ask, and what a good answer sounds like.
AskA good answer
What would you look at first on our site, and why?Specific observations about your site, your competitors and your searches, or a clear plan to find them before committing to a strategy
What will you do each month?Tasks and deliverables you can check, tied to your goals
Who will do the work?Names. If writing, development or links are passed to someone else, they tell you who and how it’s checked
How will we measure success?Enquiries, calls or sales from organic search, with impressions, clicks and rankings as early signs
How long before we see results?A range in months, with reasons, and what should happen first
How do you get links?Methods they can explain: PR, partnerships, local organisations, content people want to cite
Who owns the accounts and the content?You do. They work through access you give them
What’s the contract term and notice period?A clear term and notice period, in writing
Can I speak to a current client?Yes, or a sensible explanation of confidentiality plus other evidence of their work
What do you need from us?An honest list: access, quick approvals, information about your services, sometimes a developer’s time

On timing, anyone promising big results in weeks is either describing a quick technical fix or overselling. Our guide to how long SEO takes sets out what’s realistic.

Checklist of seven questions to ask an SEO consultant before signing a contract.
Ask every consultant on your shortlist the same questions.

Red flags to walk away from

Red flagWhy it matters
Guaranteed rankings, or “page one in 30 days”Nobody controls Google’s results. Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO warns that no one can guarantee a number one ranking
Secret or proprietary methods they won’t explainGood SEO is explainable. Secrecy usually hides tactics that break Google’s rules
A fixed number of links for a fixed feeBought links break Google’s spam policies and can cost you rankings. Packages like this are usually low-quality directories and blog networks
A cold email saying your site has errors or “isn’t ranking”Automated audits find something on every site, so the email tells you nothing about yours
Your domain, profile or analytics set up in their nameIf you part ways, you can lose access to your own data and listings
Reports full of rankings for phrases nobody searches, or your own business nameEasy wins that look good and bring in no new customers
“We’ll submit your site to search engines”You can do this free in Google Search Console in a few minutes
A long contract with no way out before any work is shownYou carry all the risk if it doesn’t work
A very low monthly fee with no detail on hours or tasksUsually means very little work, or automated work that can do harm

What an SEO consultant costs in the UK

SEO is usually priced as a monthly retainer, a fixed-price project such as an audit or a site migration, or a day rate. Prices vary widely, so compare what the money buys: the hours, the tasks and who carries them out. A cheap retainer that pays for an hour a month won’t move a competitive search, and an expensive one isn’t automatically better.

For reference, our SEO starts from £1,000 a month, on a 3-month rolling or 12-month term. Our pricing page sets out the monthly bands. Whoever you talk to, ask for the same breakdown so you can compare like with like.

Accounts and assets you should own

Whoever you hire, keep these in your business’s name and give your consultant access as a user. If a provider has already set any of them up in their own name, ask for ownership to be transferred now, while relations are good.

Checklist of six accounts a business should own itself, from the domain name to Google Ads.

Content written for you should be yours too. Check the contract says so, along with what happens to access when the work ends.

What good SEO reporting looks like

A monthly report should tell you what was done, what changed and what’s planned next, in plain English. The numbers that matter are clicks from searches that don’t include your name, enquiries or sales from organic search, and calls and direction requests from your Google Business Profile. Rankings belong in the report as supporting evidence.

You should also be able to log in to Search Console and Google Analytics yourself and see the same numbers. Our guide to monitoring search engine rankings explains what to look at. If you’re a local business, ask how they’ll measure your map visibility, and read our guide to local SEO before the first meeting.

Get it in writing

Before any work starts, the agreement should cover:

  • the scope of work and what you’ll receive each month
  • the term, notice period and any minimum commitment
  • who owns the content, accounts and data
  • costs outside the monthly fee, such as copywriting, development or software
  • how and how often you’ll get reports and meetings

Once you’ve hired someone

SEO goes faster when the business side responds quickly. Agree who approves pages and answers questions, keep a short monthly call in the diary, and tell your consultant about changes to your services, prices or website plans before they happen. A website rebuild that nobody mentions to your SEO consultant is one of the easiest ways to lose rankings you’ve paid to build.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if an SEO consultant is any good?

Ask what they’d look at first on your site and why, how they get links, and how they measure success. A good consultant gives specific, plain answers, talks about enquiries and sales as well as rankings, and can put you in touch with a current client.

What questions should I ask an SEO consultant?

Ask what they’d look at first, what they’ll do each month, who will do the work, how success will be measured, how they get links, who owns the accounts and content, and what the contract term and notice period are.

Should I hire an SEO consultant or an agency?

A freelance consultant often suits a smaller site or a single clear need. An agency suits ongoing work across technical fixes, content and links, or SEO alongside paid ads. With either, ask exactly who will work on your account.

How much does an SEO consultant cost in the UK?

Pricing is usually a monthly retainer, a fixed-price project or a day rate, and it varies widely. Compare the hours and tasks each proposal includes as well as the monthly figure.

Can an SEO consultant guarantee first page rankings?

No. Nobody controls Google’s results, and Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO warns against anyone who guarantees rankings.

Are there official SEO qualifications?

There’s no licence or official qualification for SEO in the UK, and Google doesn’t certify SEO practitioners. Training courses exist, but evidence of results and clear answers to your questions tell you more.

Rob Curtis
Rob Curtis

Founder of The Pursuit Agency in Swindon. He has worked in SEO for fifteen-odd years and leads the agency's SEO and Google Ads work for owner-led businesses across the UK.

Want this done for your business?

Tell us about your business and what you want more of. You'll speak to the person who would lead your account, and the first call is free.

Rather talk? Book a free discovery call or ring 01793 292085

Rob Curtis

Rob Curtis MCIM leads every account, with specialist partners in design, development, video and content.

Unit 4, Lancaster Place, South Marston, Swindon. Working with UK businesses.